The Brooklyn Star
Posted on | December 8, 2011 | No Comments

I don’t travel to Brooklyn that much, but dinner at The Brooklyn Star with friends seemed too good to pass up. I was busy eating junk food at home when I got a text inviting me to dinner. Obviously, I had to look at the menu online first, but once I saw Fried Pig Tail, I was sold.  After a short hop on the L rain (which was thankfully running), we arrived at the restaurant which was pretty quiet for 8pm on a Friday.
 There’s a bar area with high tables in the front & a spacious dining room in the back, with long communal tables in the center. We snagged a booth & started boozing. Our waiter explained that most of the dishes were geared to be shared, so we went right ahead & ordered the Cornbread with bacon & jalapeno (15 minute wait as it’s made to order).  We also opted for the Wedge Salad which had hard boiled eggs, croutons, bacon buttermilk dressing & a Tabasco topping.  Ok, you’re not imagining things; I just said bacon buttermilk dressing!  I normally steer well clear of salad, but this stuff was amazing!
There’s a bar area with high tables in the front & a spacious dining room in the back, with long communal tables in the center. We snagged a booth & started boozing. Our waiter explained that most of the dishes were geared to be shared, so we went right ahead & ordered the Cornbread with bacon & jalapeno (15 minute wait as it’s made to order).  We also opted for the Wedge Salad which had hard boiled eggs, croutons, bacon buttermilk dressing & a Tabasco topping.  Ok, you’re not imagining things; I just said bacon buttermilk dressing!  I normally steer well clear of salad, but this stuff was amazing!
 I’ve made cornbread plenty of times, never from scratch, but i do modify the boxed stuff to taste.  The BK Star’s cornbread was some of the best I’ve ever had.  Well worth the wait!  Fried Oyster Tacos & the aforementioned Fried Pig Tails were also ordered (seeing a theme here?).  If there was a sight to sum up pure joy, picture the 4 of us covered in spicy sauce sucking on pig tails with our hands.  I was already well satisfied & we didn’t get to our mains yet.
I’ve made cornbread plenty of times, never from scratch, but i do modify the boxed stuff to taste.  The BK Star’s cornbread was some of the best I’ve ever had.  Well worth the wait!  Fried Oyster Tacos & the aforementioned Fried Pig Tails were also ordered (seeing a theme here?).  If there was a sight to sum up pure joy, picture the 4 of us covered in spicy sauce sucking on pig tails with our hands.  I was already well satisfied & we didn’t get to our mains yet.

 Perhaps we went a bit overboard with the appetizers, because by the time our entrees arrived, I was already pretty stuffed.  With so much good food on the menu, I had a hard time choosing, but once I saw that the roast chicken had a dirty rice side, I had to go that route.  The chicken was moist, had a delicious crispy skin with a citrus glaze.  The rice, however sealed the deal.  A southern mainstay perfectly executed.
Perhaps we went a bit overboard with the appetizers, because by the time our entrees arrived, I was already pretty stuffed.  With so much good food on the menu, I had a hard time choosing, but once I saw that the roast chicken had a dirty rice side, I had to go that route.  The chicken was moist, had a delicious crispy skin with a citrus glaze.  The rice, however sealed the deal.  A southern mainstay perfectly executed.
Dan got the Shrimp & Grits which came highly recommended. I didn’t try it, but if his whimpering was any indication, it was pretty good. The Country Fried Steak with mash & gravy was also well received. Visually, the Pork Chop with mushroom spaetzle was the star. I tried it & my word was it good.

 As you can well imagine, we were all pretty damn full by now (I barely made a dent in my chicken, not for lack of effort), but we couldn’t resist the Chocolate Bread Pudding.
As you can well imagine, we were all pretty damn full by now (I barely made a dent in my chicken, not for lack of effort), but we couldn’t resist the Chocolate Bread Pudding.
We had an un-rushed, delicious meal. The food was amazing, the service was attentive without being pushy & it didn’t break the bank (60 bucks per person with booze & tip). I left more than satisfied. I guess the bar there gets busy, because on the way out, things were on & poppin’ in the front.
The Brooklyn Star: 593 Lorimer Street at Conselyea St.

Tags: Booze > Massive Portions > Offal > Pork > Southern > Umami > Williamsburg
Comments
Leave a Reply